Wednesday January 5, 2011
Why you shouldn’t praise your child’s intelligence
PARENTING
By DR JOHN MEDINA
DOES your child give up easily? It could be because of a common parenting mistake.
Ethan’s parents constantly told him how brainy he was. The wiry son of a highly educated professor in Seattle, Ethan was indeed smart.
Every time he sailed through a test, his parents would say, “You’re so smart! You can do anything, Ethan. We are so proud of you.”
Sounds nice. Sounds encouraging, right? Wrong. Little Ethan quickly learned that any academic achievement that required no effort was the behavior that defined his gift.
His parents, with the best of intentions, consistently tethered Ethan’s accomplishments to some vague, innate characteristic.
Researchers call this “appealing to fixed mindsets.”
When Ethan hit junior high school, he ran into subjects that did require effort. He could no longer sail through; for the first time, he started making mistakes.
Ethan had no idea what to do when he failed, except to conclude that he must not be smart anymore. He got discouraged, then depressed. Quite simply, Ethan quit trying, and his grades collapsed.
Research shows that Ethan’s unfortunate story is typical of kids regularly praised for some fixed characteristic.
Research shows a simple solution. Certainly, scientists don’t know everything about the brain.
But what we do know gives parents their best chance at raising smart, happy children. What should Ethan’s parents have done?
Rather than praising him for being smart, they should have praised him for working hard. On the successful completion of a test, they should not have said, “I’m so proud of you. You’re so smart.”
They should have said, “I’m so proud of you.
You must have really studied hard.” Big difference. This appeals to your child’s controllable effort rather than to mysterious, unchangeable talent. It’s called “growth mindset” praise.
More than 30 years of study show that children raised in growth-mindset homes consistently outscore their fixed-mindset peers in academic achievement.
There’s more detail about why in my new book, Brain Rules for Baby: How to Raise a Smart and Happy Child from Zero to Five.
Children with a growth mindset tend to:
·Have a refreshing attitude toward failure. They do not ruminate over their mistakes.
·Perceive errors simply as problems to be solved. “I love a challenge” is one delightfully common statement.
·Spend more time on problems — and solve those problems more often, too. Kids regularly praised for effort solve 50 to 60% more hard math problems than kids praised for intelligence.
Because they believe mistakes occur from of lack of effort, not from a lack of ability, the kids know exactly how to remedy mistakes: simply apply more effort.
The writer is a developmental molecular biologist and author of the New York Times best-seller Brain Rules. He is an affiliate Professor of Bioengineering at the University Of Washington School Of Medicine. He is also the director of the Brain Centre for Applied Learning Research at Seattle Pacific University. A father of two boys, he believes parenting is about brain development. To watch related videos and for more information, please visit www.brainrulesasia.com.
- Security guards jailed for killing alleged Nigerian conman
- Coconut yogurt anyone?
- Court postpones return of Genneva directors’ assets
- Contest for top MCA posts to be held in December
- Tee Siew Kiong on leave from MCA with immediate effect, says Chua
- Malaysia voices concern over North Korea's missile launch
- Let us find common ground on water issue, Ongkili tells Selangor
- Ex-Penang Hindu Endowment Board secretary urged to help in missing gold bars case
- Blogger denies he is Papa Gomo
- Abu Zahar sworn in as Senate president for second term
- Takeover of Sungai Nibong bus terminal leads to stand-off
- Ahmad Zahid: Armed forces, police collaboration to be strengthened
- MAS flew baby home with doctor's certification, says CEO Ahmad Jauhari
- Former top judge questions Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission
- The best ways to national unity
- EPF invests additional US$1.3b overseas
- MIDA: Investments up 44% on-year to RM49.3b in Q1
- Prague metro plans to launch love train for singles
- iGate sacks chief executive Murthy after sexual harassment probe
- Eversendai Q1 earnings slip 13.1% to RM23.68m on timing differences
- US asks judge to deny S&P's motion to dismiss fraud lawsuit
- Perdana Petroleum bidding for over RM1b contracts
- IOI Corp Q3 earnings up just 2.8% to RM567.8m (Update)
- Tenaga lifts KLCI, property stocks in focus (Update)
- CIMB maintains outperform on UMW Holdings
- Yahoo's rise in Asia offsets risk from Tumblr bet
- Asia Brands up, Kenanga Research has Outperform
- Alliance Research lowers Affin to Neutral but ups target price
- KLCI inches up in early trade, boost from PPB Group, HLFG
- Malaysia's Titan seeks up to 130,000 tonnes of naphtha
- 6.0 quake off Russia's far-east Kamchatka coastline: USGS
- Death toll rises to 21 in Indonesian mine collapse
- Dozens dead as tornado hits Oklahoma City (Updated)

- No new H7N9 cases in China for a week: government
- Villagers discover ancient ball game statue in Mexico
- British PM survives gay marriage vote
- Kerry to help ink $2.1 bn defense accord with Oman
- Yahoo unveils makeover of flickr site
- Former Asian phenom takes slow route to success
- Plenty for Hafizh as 55 is significant in his early racing career
- Yi Ting on a mission
- Razif: Indiscipline the cause of senior players’ poor performances
- Cool V Shem believes he will be too hot for rivals to handle
- Spirited Malaysian team vow to deliver against Germans
- Japan hope to reach their first semis in tourney
- KLHC to rule the roost if other teams don’t raise their game
- Malaysia have their work cut out in the World League
- Gobi’s fate to be decided by MHC’s administrative committee
- Andre nails it with last jump
- Grace hammers home a point with two golds
- Delia one step away from main draw after easy win
- Sharon believes KPT circuit is excellent for squash’s future
- Nadal and Williams are looking unbeatable leaving rivals stunned
- Rape accused defends marriage to 13-year-old, says it was mutual
- MAS flew baby home with doctor's certification, says CEO Ahmad Jauhari
- Wee: MCA shouldn’t join Government
- The best ways to national unity
- ‘Boycott will be self-defeating’
- AirAsia: Child not allowed on board because of chicken pox
- Mustapa against call to boycott products of Chinese firms
- Group upset over man marrying underage victim
- Zahid: I will not interfere with decisions of HODs
- Former top judge questions Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission
- Rape accused defends marriage to 13-year-old, says it was mutual
- Malindo set to operate from Subang Skypark
- MAS flew baby home with doctor's certification, says CEO Ahmad Jauhari
- Revival of abandoned RM1.4bil 79-storey Plaza Rakyat near Pudu bus terminal
- The best ways to national unity
- ‘Boycott will be self-defeating’
- Not taken for a good ride and not ungrateful
- Court: Sosma not applicable to Yazid and two others
- Zahid: I will not interfere with decisions of HODs
- Indonesian who brought mum to Penang for treatment falls to her death

