Published: Tuesday November 20, 2012 MYT 8:54:00 PM
Updated: Tuesday November 20, 2012 MYT 9:53:55 PM
Man gets 12-years jail for consensual sex with underage daughter who gives birth
By QISHIN TARIQ
KUALA LUMPUR: A 54-year-old man pleaded guilty to having sex with his underage daughter but claimed that both of them did not know they were father and daughter until it came to light when the girl got pregnant.
He was sentenced to 12 years prison and seven strokes of the whip by Sessions Court judge Emelia Kaswati Mohamad Khalid who scolded him when he claimed naivety and a lack of religious education as reasons for his crime.
“How can you still be naive at this age? Even without religious education, do you think it is acceptable to rape a teenager,” she asked.
“You are old, at an age where people are going for their Haji, you will now go to prison,” she told the unemployed man, who started weeping when he heard his sentence.
The man, who was unrepresented, admitted he raped the then 13-year-old girl in her bedroom at the PPR Kampung Muhibbah flat on Jalan Puchong, Cheras at 1am in July 2010.
It is learnt that the man and the girl's mother had lived together many years ago and he had left her without realising she was pregnant.
He then went on to marry and divorce another woman after having two children with her.
Two years ago, he came back into the girl's mother's life and they resumed living together but the woman did not reveal that girl was his daughter.
The girl was then 13-years-old and according to the facts of the case, the girl asked her mother and the man to sleep in her room on the same mattress one night.
After some time, the man took off his pants and had sex with her.
In her victim impact statement (VIS) the teen told the court that the sex was consensual and she did not know then that he was her biological father.
A medical check in Aug 2010 confirmed she was pregnant, and she gave birth in April the next year.
When she found out she was pregnant, she told her mother, who instructed her to keep the child and also revealed that the man was her biological father.
When asked by the judge if she was upset when she found out she was pregnant, the teenager said she didn't mind as she felt it was the outcome of a consensual relationship with the man.
The teenager, who wore a red blouse and matching red ribbon appeared unfazed when giving her statement and was even seen smiling.
She told the court that she was moved around different children's homes while she was pregnant and had her daughter sent to a different home after she gave birth.
She added that the taunting she received for being pregnant in a children's home did embarrass and traumatise her.
During sentencing, Judge Emelia said it was the role of parents to protect their children from such predators and told the teenager not to let her daughter make the same mistake she and her mother had made.
Earlier, DPP Ooi Chean Ling revealed that the man had previously been charged with breaking and entering and rape, though he was not convicted of rape in the earlier case.
- Penang freak storm: Prayer held at Jln Macalister for Lim Chin Aik
- Boy dies while sliding down school staircase railing
- Immigration officer chides UNHCR staff for delaying court process
- Lahad Datu: Esscom dismisses claims of clashes with 400 Sulu gunmen

- Bar Council: Coversion to Islam of two Hindu kids in Negri Sembilan unconstitutional
- Three nabbed hours after robbing book shop, mobile phone outlet in Nibong Tebal
- Hisham: Special squad to be set up to improve motorbike lanes
- Hair salon owner jailed for cannabis possession, wife goes free
- Prosecution wins appeal against Yazid Sufaat's acquittal over terror charge
- RCI on Sabah illegals: Problem lies with integrity of enforcers, says Upko
- Lynas drops defamation suit against Save Malaysia Stop Lynas
- UNHCR: Only 10pc of refugees in Malaysia resettled last year
- Families of Batang Kali massacre send David Cameron "please apologise" postcards
- Myanmar temporarily stops supply of workers to Malaysia

- Sabah state assembly: Argument over position of Opposition leader
- Berjaya Sports Toto FY earnings down 5.1% to RM384.97m (Update)
- Market sentiment turns for the better, CIMB, Maybank up
- Westports to see 25% cut in fuel costs with LWK transmission system
- Hibiscus Petroleum unit gets US$10m investment
- Aeon Credit Services to expand fee business
- MMHE: Oil price to determine customers' decisions on projects
- Malaysia's BiotechCorp raises profile at Montreal World Congress
- 1MDB to raise US$1b from power assets
- Securities Commission to host PRS exhibition on June 29
- Maybank, Tenaga lift KLCI out of the red (Update)
- Mudajaya scouts for regional power plants to boost recurring income
- Astro launches 11 new channels, 5 new packages
- Glove makers buck cautious market
- Fitters advances on venture into renewable energy sector
- AmResearch maintains "Buy" on Sarawak Cable Bhd
- Brazil shaken by largest protests in 20 years
- Bollywood star Shah Rukh Khan faces baby sex test inquiry
- Afghan forces take over security from NATO
- At least 60 feared dead as monsoon lashes north India
- Defiant Snowden promises more leaks
- Tensions rise as Bulgarian protesters pressure PM to resign
- 'No alternative' to Palestinian state: Bill Clinton in Israel
- Obama defends Internet snooping program
- Brutal golf course dooms US Open hopefuls in final round
- Queen’s title will boost Wimbledon bid, says Andy Murray
- Chong Wei misses the days top players bring out the best in him
- Results worldwide
- Malaysia target 30 golds at ASG
- World No. 1 hopes Daren and Wei Feng will step up their game
- Kisona stays focused ahead of Asian Junior Championships
- Spurs on brink of another NBA title
- Clarke: Hard for Warner to retain Test spot
- Costa retains Tour of Switzerland crown
- Justin Rose out-duels Mickelson to capture US Open title
- McIlroy loses his cool and takes it out on club
- Aussie confident his Day will come at a Major
- Mickelson suffers most agonising Open near-miss
- The long wait for 15th Major continues for world No. 1 Woods
- Penang freak storm: Architect: force that hit Lim’s car would crush anything
- Penang freak storm: ‘I saw his spirit, he was crying’
- EPF plans ruling for new contributors
- ‘Arigato’ for Japan’s decision on visas
- Penang freak storm: Family grieves as search gets called off
- 15-year-old arrested after ordering five air rifles with brass bullets online
- Meth head snatch thief in the bag
- Woman slashed by rival meat seller
- Penang freak storm: Inquest to be held to certify death of missing hawker
- Penang freak storm: Search called off for sake of heritage buildings
- ‘Arigato’ for Japan’s decision on visas
- EPF plans ruling for new contributors
- Penang freak storm: Architect: force that hit Lim’s car would crush anything
- Penang freak storm: ‘I saw his spirit, he was crying’
- Blue form route to AirAsia X IPO
- MAHB to impose penalties on UEMC-Bina Puri for KLIA2 delay
- 15-year-old arrested after ordering five air rifles with brass bullets online
- Zahid: Government to review guidelines for hiring foreign workers to curb abuse, improve work conditions
- Address food hygiene issue seriously, says Chua
- Astro launches 11 new channels, 5 new packages

