KUALA LUMPUR: Political cartoonist Zulkiflee S.M. Anwar Ulhaque won his claim against the Government and four others over the seizure of 66 of his books and a collage in 2010.

High Court Judicial Commissioner Vazeer Alam Mydin Meera held that the continued detention of the books and the collage without any further action by the police was unwarranted and unlawful.

“The books and collage were suspected to contain seditious materials. It would have been a simple determination to make. Surely, it would not take two years to make that determination,” he said.

In a suit filed last year, Zulkiflee, popularly known as Zunar, claimed he had suffered damages and losses due to the seizure of the items by the police.

Vazeer said evidence was adduced that several bookshops had returned the books to the plaintiffs whilst some others refused to sell them.

“The continued detention of the books had deprived Zulkiflee of his livelihood,” he said.

However, Vazeer held that Zulkiflee’s detention was lawful and that the defendants had explained to him why he had to be taken to several police stations after his arrest.

“I find that explanation to be plausible. In the circumstance, I find the initial arrest is lawful,” he said.

Zulkiflee’s lawyer N. Surendran said they might consider appealing on the ruling that the detention was legal.

In his lawsuit, Zulkiflee said a police team led by one Asst Supt Arikrishna Apparau raided his office in Brickfields at 4pm on Sept 24, 2010, and seized all his books, which he was preparing to launch in a widely publicised event.

He had named the Government, Home Ministry, Asst Supt Arikrishna, Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Ismail Omar and Asst Supt Marina Hashim, who led a team to seize the books from the publisher Malaysiakini.com on Sept 25, as defendants.

• IHH Healthcare earnings up 3.6% to RM127.27m
• Petronas Dagangan Q1 earnings down 3.7% to RM237m
• Japan's tumble drags key regional, European markets lower (Update)
• KUB in JV with Singapore's Hiap Seng for Petronas project
• TDM to plant 5,000ha of new trees every year in Kalimantan
• KLCI falls to low of 1,765, rattled by Japan, HK
• Japan stocks crash on volatile bonds, weak China data; Nikkei ends down 7.3%
• MISC posts RM300m net profit in Q1, sees challenging year ahead (Update)
• KL Kepong slips to low of RM21.36 as quarterly profit drops
• Maybank's Q1 earnings up 11.8% to RM1.506b (Update)
• Lafarge Cement positive on markets, mulls expanding capacity
• Dayang Enterprise awards RM705m contract to Perdana Petroleum
• KLCI pauses, Japan, Hong Kong key indices slide (Update)
• ECM Libra plans to exit PN17 by year-end
• China HSBC flash PMI hits 7-mth low, fans growth fears

• Ranger, militant killed in Thai south shootout
• Japan man, 80, scales Everest, sets record
• Philippines vows to defend territory against China
• S. Korean girl killed by suicide jumper
• Ecuador warns satellite could hit rocket remains
• Short-story writer Davis wins Booker International Prize
• Two babies among US tornado victims
• Anti-Islamist protests flare following London attack
• 'British solider' butchered in suspected Islamist attack (Updated)

• Rugby: Former All Black coach Henry on misconduct charge
• Ice queen Nicol into British Open quarters
• Australia to consider following ban on anchor putters
• Intxausti wins 16th stage, Nibali still keeps pink jersey
• Indonesia drawn to meet China again – in knockout stage
• Results worldwide
• Malacca sprinter Mohd Azam Masri out to create history by winning five events in MSSM meet
• Athletics runs in the veins of Vallabouy family
• Chinese long jumper Jinzhe claims another Olympic scalp
• Dane Jorgensen’s wish is to avoid Chinese ace Lin Dan in World Championships
• National badminton team’s lack of depth a glaring factor in home tourney
• Khim Wah-V Shem perform above expectations in Sudirman Cup debut
• Jindapon aims to qualify for 2016 Olympics
• Kenichi’s goal is to take Japan into Sudirman Cup semi-finals
• Dong-keun shows he’s a capable replacement

• Please wait.

• Actress’ barking pet saves her from attacker in late night incident
• Transport Ministry reveals new FT registration plate to start with W1A
• In China, food scares put Mao's self-sufficiency goal at risk
• Tian Chua, Haris Ibrahim, Tamrin Ghafar to spend the night in lockup (Update)
• What comes after WYY?
• Verdict ends three years of restlessness for family, says Sosilawati's daughter
• All four accused guilty in murder of Sosilawati Lawiya and three others (Update)
• Chromebook to help rural pupils leapfrog into parity with urban peers
• Astro and Maxis to deliver new-age TV service in Klang Valley
• Japan's wartime brothels were wrong, says 91-year-old veteran