Published: Wednesday January 9, 2013 MYT 5:05:00 PM
Computer vendor loses appeal against decision on Microsoft copyright lawsuit
By QISHIN TARIQ
PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal here has maintained a High Court decision in favor of Microsoft Corp, in a copyright lawsuit against a local computer dealer for pre-installing unlicensed Microsoft software into new computers it sold.
A three-member panel Wednesday chaired by Justice Zaharah Ibrahim unanimously dismissed Vital IT Marketing Services Sdn Bhd's application to appeal against the High Court's decision, saying the judgement by the then judicial commisioner, Hanipah Farikullah was good.
"Therefore, we find no reason to interfere with the judgement," said Zaharah.
The panel, which included justices Mah Weng Kwai and K. Ananthan, also ordered Vital IT to pay Microsoft RM30,000 in costs.
On April 4 last year, Hanipah, now a High Court judge, awarded Microsoft an injunction against Vital IT prohibiting it from further infringing on Microsoft's copyright.
She also ordered Vital IT to surrender any pirated copies of Microsoft software in its possession and awarded Microsoft damages (still to be assessed) and court costs.
In her grounds of judgement, Hanipah said the testimony by computer technician Nadzri Sulaiman verified the software was unlicensed, adding that Vital IT too admitted to selling the laptop.
"In my view, the plaintiff (Microsoft) has proven that the defendant (Vital IT) sold a computer which was loaded with unlicensed software, thus infringing the plaintiff's copyright," said Hanifah.
Counsel for Microsoft, Ken St James, told reporters that the software company had no choice but to clamp down on companies that loaded unlicensed software.
"It is highly profitable for such companies when they avoid paying licensing fees, which allows them to sell with higher margins or at lower prices with no loss, resulting in unfair competition against companies that legally include software on their computers," he said.
Co-counsel Harleen Kaur said members of public could determine if their computer has legal software by either checking it for a Certificate of Authenticity, and ensuring that user manuals, end-user agreements and DVDs for the software were bundled with the purchase.
- Khaled: DAP did well in GE13 by 'simply making promises'
- Maximus: No private land will be used for Sabah marine park
- PM Najib: BN has to adapt to remain relevant
- Centre to train Sabahan youths to run renewable energy systems launched
- It takes nearly 72 hours to get a new polycarbonate passport now
- Najib: Rallies only lead to chaos
- Leave no stone unturned in latest death in lock-up case
- Give birth naturally, women urged
- King launches ‘Colours of 1Malaysia’ at Dataran Merdeka
- Housewife extorted over nude pics
- Election Commission promises utmost transparency in redelineation exercise
- Barisan leaders: 'All for one and one party for all’ a good idea
- Guan Eng confident of Pakatan unity despite pressure
- Too blessed to be stressed
- It can take longer to get a passport for time being
- Travel Picks: Top 10 golf resorts around the world
- Chinese premier criticizes EU move on trade measures
- Justice Department opposes AMR's $20 million severance for CEO Horton
- News Corp to take charge of up to $1.4 billion this quarter
- Wall Street Week Ahead: Investors look for signs in the rally's break
- Unhappy with how your fave series is faring? Amazon gives you a say
- Visa, Mastercard ask U.S. court to declare card fees are lawful
- Wall Street posts first weekly loss since mid-April on Fed angst
- IMF's Lagarde escapes formal investigation in court
- Politics of development pays dividend
- A thematic play seen
- Sarawak counters hogging the limelight
- Getting GST acceptance will be tough
- A yen for the unloved dollar standard
- Bitten by the music bug
- Sweet revenge as Froch defeats Kessler
- Pandelela-Mun Yee and Yan Yee-Jun Hoong bag bronze medals in Mexico
- World No. 1 Nicol sinks Waters to reach British Open final
- China confident of sweeping aside their final opponents
- Koreans in the final despite Dong-keun’s loss
- Macdonald and Marques share the lead
- McIlroy among big names who miss the cut as Molinari leads
- Kuchar leads in weather-hit second round
- Two tied at the top as rain stops play in the Bahamas
- Nico Rosberg revels in the rain as Mercedes stamp their mark
- Whitmarsh: McLaren’s hopes were too high this season
- Affendi brushes off hand injury to win CP130 race in Terengganu
- Hafizh needs to step up a gear after coming in fifth
- Vignesa right on track to retain GT Open title
- Dragons’ Melton confident of getting the better of Pringle in Game 2
- The Wall Street Journal: Anwar asked Jusuf to broker deal over GE13
- It takes nearly 72 hours to get a new polycarbonate passport now
- Housewife extorted over nude pics
- Election Commission promises utmost transparency in redelineation exercise
- Give birth naturally, women urged
- Najib: Rallies only lead to chaos
- ‘Harry Potter Wong’ casts his spell
- Saiful marries TV3 newscaster decked in Zang Toi finery
- Leave no stone unturned in latest death in lock-up case
- Too blessed to be stressed
- Give birth naturally, women urged
- Too blessed to be stressed
- It takes nearly 72 hours to get a new polycarbonate passport now
- Indian warships visit Malaysian waters
- ‘Harry Potter Wong’ casts his spell
- Theme parks and long holiday help fill Johor hotel rooms
- Exemplary educators
- The Wall Street Journal: Anwar asked Jusuf to broker deal over GE13
- DAP’s Ngeh in hot water over subservient tweet
- Why field candidates against allies, asks Shamsul
RSS
