Thursday, February 21, 2013
Triumph passengers bring class action against Carnival
(Reuters) - The owner of the stricken Carnival Triumph cruise ship was hit by a lawsuit seeking class action status for stranding more than 3,000 passengers for five days on a ship without electricity or adequate sanitation.
Carnival Corp should be held liable for physical and emotional anguish inflicted on the passengers as well as punitive damages, according to the lawsuit by Matt and Melissa Crusan. The lawsuit was filed on Monday in U.S. federal court in Miami.
The Carnival Triumph cruise ship is towed towards the dock at the port of Mobile, Alabama, February 14, 2013. REUTERS/ Lyle Ratliff |
The Triumph was towed into Mobile, Alabama on Thursday, four days after a fire knocked out the ship's power while it was off the coast of Mexico.
The lawsuit alleged the world's largest cruise company failed to provide a seaworthy ship. In addition, "motivated solely by financial gain" Carnival negligently brought the Triumph to Mobile, where it would be repaired, rather than a closer Mexican port. That decision extended the trip by 350 miles, the plaintiffs said.
Passengers were exposed to disease as sewage and "human waste sloshed around the vessel as the vessel listed while drifting and/or while under tow," according to the lawsuit.
A Carnival spokesman, Vance Gulliksen, said the company does not comment on pending litigation.
The lawsuit seeks to represent all of the passengers on the stricken cruise.
The complaint said that the Triumph ticket limits passengers' rights to bring a class action, but that provision should be voided by Carnival's negligence in using an unseaworthy vessel and not towing the ship to the nearest port.
Carnival has offered Triumph passengers $500, reimbursement for their transportation and many onboard costs, and given them a credit toward a future cruise equal to the amount they paid for the Triumph vacation.
Jim Walker, who specializes in representing cruise ship passengers, told Reuters last week that the compensation offer was probably more than Triumph passengers would likely win in court. Walker is not involved in this suit and said he is unlikely to bring a case.
The class action lawsuit, which was filed by the Lipcon, Margulies, Alsina & Winkleman law firm in Miami, is at least the second by a Triumph passenger. On Friday, Cassie Terry of Brazoria County, Texas sued Carnival.
Michael Winkleman, an attorney with Lipcon, Margulies could not be reached for comment.
Like the Crusans, Terry sued for the conditions aboard the ship, which lacked working toilets and proper ventilation.
The case is Matt Crusan and Melissa Crusan v Carnival Corp, U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, No. 13-20592.
(Reporting By Tom Hals in Wilmington, Delaware; editing by Carol Bishopric)
- Families of victims, accused fill up court room for Sosilawati Lawiya verdict
- New crime prevention department to be set up

- Syariah Court can annul child’s marriage, says SIS
- A-G: Prosecution to proceed with statutory rape charges against Riduan
- Women’s groups laud A-G’s promise to press statutory rape charges against Riduan
- Probe into why teen withdrew rape report
- What comes after WYY?
- Prime Minister to address global women conference
- Sabah security is new Defence Minister’s priority
- Gerakan may accept government positions
- EC gazettes official GE13 results
- Only AGM can tell Chua to quit, says Ling
- Mind-blowing feats by mental giant
- PKR mulls postponing party polls
- PSM to review ties with Pakatan after GE13 losses
- Alliance Neutral on Axiata, ups target price to RM7
- Deleum top loser, down 11.3% after disappointing results
- Maybank KE Research maintains Hold on AirAsia
- Public Invest Research ups Uzma target price to RM2.86
- Malaysia's blue chips fall more than 6pts in early trade
- Profit taking may weigh on Malaysian equities
- HP raises 2013 outlook as Whitman's plan takes hold
- Bernanke says more progress needed before stimulus pullback
- Wall Street falters in volatile session on Fed worries
- Aeon director: GST won’t affect group
- Petronas Chemicals Group to invest RM3bil in capital expenditure
- Weak CPO prices hit Boustead profit
- April CPI up 1.7% on higher food prices
- Report: AirAsia X sets indicative price for IPO
- MAEI sees 3%-4% rise in electrical, electronics exports
- Ice queen Nicol into British Open quarters
- Australia to consider following ban on anchor putters
- Intxausti wins 16th stage, Nibali still keeps pink jersey
- Indonesia drawn to meet China again – in knockout stage
- Results worldwide
- Malacca sprinter Mohd Azam Masri out to create history by winning five events in MSSM meet
- Athletics runs in the veins of Vallabouy family
- Chinese long jumper Jinzhe claims another Olympic scalp
- Dane Jorgensen’s wish is to avoid Chinese ace Lin Dan in World Championships
- National badminton team’s lack of depth a glaring factor in home tourney
- Khim Wah-V Shem perform above expectations in Sudirman Cup debut
- Jindapon aims to qualify for 2016 Olympics
- Kenichi’s goal is to take Japan into Sudirman Cup semi-finals
- Dong-keun shows he’s a capable replacement
- Harrison makes swift U-turn
- What comes after WYY?
- Actress’ barking pet saves her from attacker in late night incident
- Probe into why teen withdrew rape report
- A-G: Prosecution to proceed with statutory rape charges against Riduan
- 'British solider' butchered in suspected Islamist attack
- Family demands full inquiry into death of shooting suspect under remand
- Syariah Court can annul child’s marriage, says SIS
- Astro and Maxis to deliver new-age TV service in Klang Valley
- PSM to review ties with Pakatan after GE13 losses
- Gerakan may accept government positions
- Actress’ barking pet saves her from attacker in late night incident
- What comes after WYY?
- Chromebook to help rural pupils leapfrog into parity with urban peers
- Free entry to MATTA Fair in Penang
- Asean flavour in Invest M’sia confab
- Petronas Chemicals Group to invest RM3bil in capital expenditure
- Report: AirAsia X sets indicative price for IPO
- We have to be humane to all who are put under arrest
- We must look at language as an asset
- Prime Minister to address global women conference

