McGuinness, a deck hand on the Atlantic Challenger, on a fishing vessel moored in the harbour in Killybegs, western Ireland. Photo: Paul Faith/AFP
When he finished school, Daragh McGuinness knew he wanted to join a fishing crew but now, at 23, he fears climate change may kill off the industry that has sustained his family for generations.
"It's a massive problem," he said in the pilothouse of the Atlantic Challenge trawler, where he works as a deckhand, docked in the port of Killybegs in northwest Ireland.
"It could really finish the fishing, in Ireland anyway at least."
Soaring temperatures in the North Atlantic Ocean over the summer months have raised fears that fish could be pushed to colder waters, heaping pressure on the already struggling industry.
At the end of July, the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) announced that average surface temperatures in the North Atlantic had reached a new record high of 24.9ºC (76.8ºF).
The Atlantic Challenge, like many vessels sailing out of Killybegs, catches blue whiting and mackerel, which are highly prized on international markets, returning to port one or two days after a catch so produce is fresh.
"It would just concern you that you would be pushed further, too far north and then it wouldn't be viable to come back to Killybegs," McGuinness explained.
Sean O'Donoghue, chief executive of the Killybegs Fishermen's Organisation, said climate change was having a "dramatic effect" on white fish stocks such as cod which prefer colder waters.
Extreme situation
He feared it was "only a matter of time" before so-called pelagic fish such as mackerel, blue whiting and herring move north permanently.
"If we continue with the warming of the waters, it is inevitable, the pelagic species will move totally out of the waters. And we could end up that we have very little fish," he said.
Among the trends emerging, he added, were more mackerel being caught by the Icelandic fleet, while his members were catching more species like anchovies and sardines, which are typically found in warmer southern waters, prompting "overall concern".
The temperature record set in July was particularly worrying as it came weeks before the North Atlantic typically reaches peak temperatures in September.
In June, the NOAA recorded what it characterised as a Category 4 or "extreme" marine heatwave off the coasts of Ireland and Britain.
Glenn Nolan, who heads oceanographic and climate services at Ireland's Marine Institute, said the month saw "significant" temperatures, 4-5 degrees in excess of what would be normal off the country's coast in the summer months.
"When you're seeing a temperature at 24.5 or 21, as we saw in some of the coastal bays around the county of Galway... it's way above what you would ordinarily expect," he said.
Nolan said he expected a specific study attributing the spike in temperatures in June and July to climate change in due course.
Double whammy
The UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), which assesses the science related to climate change, has attributed the intensity of marine heatwaves to global warming for decades, he noted.
"The IPCC have already looked at marine heatwaves in general and they have high confidence that they can attribute them to man-made climate change," the Galway-based expert said.
Nolan said the extreme temperatures could create the conditions for changes to fish migration, and pointed to algal blooms in warm waters causing "problems typically for shellfish and finfish".
For Irish fishing, the situation is a double whammy, as the industry has been hit by lost EU fishing quotas after Brexit, Britain's departure from the bloc at the end of 2020.
EU member Ireland saw a 15% cut to fishing quotas by 2025 as part of the last-minute trade deal between London and Brussels.
"Unfortunately the deal that was done disproportionally hit Ireland," said O'Donoghue.
"The net effect of it is that Ireland is paying 40% of the transfer of fish to Britain (from the EU)."
He now wants to see changes to EU fisheries policy to reflect the impact of the Brexit cuts on Ireland's fleet and to mitigate the effects of climate change on his members' catch.
"We're not happy with the way things are on the Common Fisheries Policy at the moment. They need to be changed and Brexit and climate change have to be taken on board," O'Donoghue said. – AFP
