It’s not just fake headshots and misleading websites: Apparent fraudsters have attempted to feign legitimacy with false press releases about venture-capital fundraises and bogus claims about partnerships with industry giants. — Bloomberg
When Jakob-Moritz Eberl clicked on a link to the website of a crypto company, he was stunned at what he saw: his own face looking back at him.
Eberl’s headshot was displayed under the name “Mason Jones” and the title “Senior Blockchain Engineer” as one of six men the site claimed were on the team behind InfinityStakeChain. A near-duplicate website for a platform called FlexyStakes used the same photos above different names, identifying Eberl as “Noel Brennan”. Eberl, a social scientist at the University of Vienna who doesn’t even own any crypto, had no idea why his picture was on the sites.
“I’m not associated with crypto,” he said in an interview. “I’m not following crypto. I have to honestly say I still don't understand crypto fully.”
When former FTX chief executive officer Sam Bankman-Fried went to prison following his conviction on fraud charges earlier this year, many in the crypto industry breathed a sigh of relief that the industry could turn the page following years of scandal. Yet scams continue to haunt the asset class, and there are signs they have picked up again amid this year’s rebound in the market.
It’s not just fake headshots and misleading websites: Apparent fraudsters have attempted to feign legitimacy with false press releases about venture-capital fundraises and bogus claims about partnerships with industry giants. In some cases, the false information has leaked into trusted industry data sources.
Both InfinityStakeChain and FlexyStakes issued press releases that were published on wire services, local news sites and Yahoo! Finance claiming that they had raised US$12mil (RM56.49mil) from investors led by Binance, the world’s largest crypto exchange. On their websites, they also claim partnerships with other big names in the industry, including Polygon, Avalanche, dydx and Fantom.
Binance and the others each confirmed to Bloomberg that they had never worked with either of these startups.
In a sector where VC activity is closely watched by traders hunting for signals about which tokens to buy, an investment from big names like Andreessen Horowitz or Dragonfly could inspire traders to snap up a new project’s token and boost its price. With Bitcoin and other tokens surging upward this year and VC funding rebounding, the risk is high for both retail and institutional investors looking to take advantage of the market’s resurgence.
“It’s fraud, especially if you’re putting up these websites,” said PitchBook crypto analyst Robert Le, who identified InfinityStakeChain and FlexyStakes among a group of crypto startups peddling false information about fundraising. Inquiries to the two projects from Bloomberg went unanswered.
InfinityStakeChain and FlexyStakes both used the same promotional language and listed the same partners on their websites, though InfinityStakeChain’s site became inactive in the past month. They even claimed the same office address at a quiet commercial property in Melbourne, Australia.
The six-level office building is home to an empty first floor full of abandoned desks, some shipping companies, a medical centre and a construction office, but there’s no sign of FlexyStakes or InfinityStakeChain.
A receptionist for one of the building’s tenants said that, to her knowledge, no company with either of those names had rented space there in the past two years.
The building’s manager, Colliers International Group, did not reply to an email seeking further confirmation.
It’s unknown what the motives are for FlexyStakes and InfinityStakeChain. Le said PitchBook, which tracks venture-capital data, has seen an increase in fraudulent activity in the digital-asset space recently and some projects are simply blatant scams whose fake fundraising announcements could lure unsuspecting victims to a malicious site.
‘Almost on a daily basis’
“All they want to do is get you to come to the website, connect your wallet to use the thing, and they steal all your funds,” he said. “We see so many fake projects that fundraise and they’ll put out fake press releases. I see it almost on a daily basis.”
Scams can appear alarmingly fast. Just a few hours after Tether Holdings Ltd announced a new synthetic dollar token on Monday, the company’s CEO Paolo Ardoino posted on X that it “seems there are already multiple websites trying to impersonate our new product Alloy by Tether. Don’t fall for it.”
When it comes to InfinityStakeChain and FlexyStakes, Eberl wasn’t the only one whose headshot was misappropriated. He also recognised two other faces, including the purported founder of both companies.
Eberl studies communication and misinformation around politics and health, and lately he’s focused on public reactions to Covid-19 policies in Austria. He recognised the pair from the X social-media platform since they had both posted about Covid policies in Austria.
Both individuals confirmed to Bloomberg that they also were not involved with the crypto startups. The other three individuals whose photos were featured on the websites also confirmed to Bloomberg that they were in no way connected to either project.
For Eberl, the incident was disturbing, even though he’s used to fielding hateful comments and online harassment over his research. His wife recently watched the Netflix documentary Bitconned and he was concerned about being targeted by a crypto scam.
He was even fearful that an inquiry from Bloomberg, which included a Zoom link for a videoconference interview, was part of some ploy. So he asked if he could send the meeting invitation from his own account in order to make sure he didn’t click on a malicious link.
Most of all, he was also worried about being connected to something potentially fraudulent that could harm his reputation and hurt unsuspecting victims.
“I have no idea how I deserved this,” Eberl said.
Another case of crypto-VC misinformation was on display recently with a company called Candle Labs. Multiple data and news platforms including Crunchbase, PitchBook and Silicon Valley Journals incorrectly reported that the company had raised US$48mil (RM225.98mil) in a Series B, or later-stage, venture funding round.
Sam Safahi, 21, founded the crypto startup in 2022 alongside some friends and his father, Alan Safahi. The elder Safahi, who had previously served on the board of Ripple Labs, is now serving a 40-month sentence in federal prison for fraud and money-laundering convictions related to a US$2.7mil (RM12.71mil) prepaid debit card scam.
The younger Safahi said in an interview that the company did not raise US$48mil (RM225.98mil) and he was unsure how that information circulated. “We raised US$1.2mil (RM5.64mil), mostly from family or friends,” he said.
Whether the incorrect data about Candle Labs’ US$48mil (RM225.98mil) was purposefully or mistakenly provided to these data platforms doesn’t change the fact that the misinformation has lingered. The company eventually shut down last year after it received a letter from the US Securities and Exchange Commission implying that its CNDL token was an unregistered security, according to Safahi.
Mysterious fundraising news
“When my father gets out of prison, we were planning on eventually working with the SEC to restart it, to make it work,” he said.
Silicon Valley Journals said in an email to Bloomberg that it had gotten the information from Crunchbase and subsequently updated the article on Candle Labs’ fundraise to include an attribution to Crunchbase. Crunchbase has an article referencing a US$48mil (RM225.98mil) fundraise, as well as a US$1,000 (RM4,708) fundraise listed on the company’s data page.
The Candle Labs data page also had a line that read: “This is a fraudulent startup – if you receive a recruitment offer from these guys ignore it.” Representatives of Crunchbase declined to be interviewed for this story.
Following Bloomberg’s inquiry, it removed the sentence alleging fraud at Candle Labs from the company’s data page.
A PitchBook spokesperson said that the information had come from “published sources”. After a review, the data tracker chose to take the entry off its website.
With so much misinformation afoot, PitchBook has had to change how it tracks the crypto industry, Le said. When a funding round is announced, Le often will speak directly to the listed investors, the firms’ limited partners and the founders themselves to confirm that they’re all involved.
He also often corroborates the raise using government filings, if they’re available. “We take more of a grain of salt in the crypto space for a fundraise announcement than in the traditional VC space,” he said.
Another new wrinkle in his efforts to combat misinformation: Artificial intelligence is making it more difficult to detect what’s real and what’s not. More fraudsters are likely using chatbots like ChatGPT to write their website language and the white papers that explain their project, Le said, and the result is that scam projects come off as more polished than they did in the past.
“They used to have all these grammar mistakes, and you can just tell that it’s fake,” he said.
Bots and humans
Social media is another complicating factor when it comes to the spread of misinformation online, Le noted. He said that there are bots that execute crypto trades based on news and social media posts, which means that false information can artificially boost token prices.
And it’s not just bots who fall for it. Actual humans are particularly vulnerable when it comes to financial information and there are few safeguards on social media sites to prevent falsehoods from spreading, said Svitlana Volkova, chief AI scientist at engineering services firm Aptima Inc, whose research has focused on crypto misinformation.
“People share information without prior verification and it’s being reshared and it gets viral,” she said. The misinformation poses a risk not just to crypto traders, but to venture capitalists themselves.
VC firms in the crypto space have been criticised for not conducting enough due diligence and ultimately backing fraudulent startups like FTX. It’s common for crypto founders to stretch the truth, said Roger Royse, partner at law firm Haynes Boone.
‘Suspension of reality’
“Here in Silicon Valley, where I practice, it's kind of the nature of being a startup founder, that people have a lot of hubris that borders on a suspension of reality,” Royse said.
The question of how far founders can go when it comes to self-aggrandisement has been brought up in cases such as the one against Elizabeth Holmes and her blood-testing startup Theranos.
While founders may believe they have the potential to succeed on a high level, Royse said that doesn’t mean they can claim to have accomplished things they haven’t. And publicly lying about a funding round, including the amount raised, and getting other VCs to invest based on that information could pose a legal problem.
“If there's a misrepresentation of a material fact, and that induces the investor to invest, that is the basis of a fraud claim,” he said.
As for Eberl, the social scientist in Vienna, it’s unclear whether he can get his image removed from the FlexyStakes website.
“On some level, I guess I feel violated by the crypto scam,” he said, while adding that his academic curiosity has also been piqued: “On the other, I just find it extremely weird and I find this connection extremely intriguing.” – Bloomberg
#JanganKenaScam
